Autism, ageing, and premature death by Erich Kofmel

7 April is World Health Day. In 2017, the World Health Organization (WHO) decided to dedicate that day to "Depression". To commemorate both the United Nations' World Autism Awareness Day (2 April) as well as World Health Day, Autistic Minority International organized a public side event/thematic briefing for the members of the UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities on Monday, 3 April 2017, 1.45-2.45 pm, at Palais des Nations, the European headquarters of the UN, in Geneva, Switzerland.

Theme: "Ageing and Premature Death on the Autism Spectrum"

Speakers: Wenn Lawson, psychologist, researcher, lecturer (Australia), Cos Michael, autistic autism consultant (United Kingdom), Alanna Rose Whitney, Autistic Acceptance Activism Alliance (Canada). Chair: Erich Kofmel, President, Autistic Minority International.

This was our fourth annual side event held during the spring session of the Committee mandated to monitor the implementation of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) in all 177 countries that have ratified it. To the best of our knowledge our event was once more the only commemoration of World Autism Awareness Day at the United Nations in Geneva. All other related UN-based activities were concentrated in New York, even though major decisions with regard to autistic children and adults are made in Geneva, both in the human rights mechanisms and at the WHO. We therefore believe that it is important that actually autistic persons show presence here as well, on this our day.

According to the WHO, depression is the leading cause of disability worldwide. More than 300 million people are living with depression, and even in high-income countries 50% of people with depression do not get treatment. Depression is an important risk factor for suicide, which claims over eight hundred thousand lives each year, 75% of them in low- and middle-income countries. Every 40 seconds someone dies by suicide. It is the second leading cause of death among 15-29-year-olds. There are more deaths from suicide than from war and homicide together.

Many autistic persons never reach old age, falling victim to depression and suicide much earlier in their lives. We believe that depression and suicide in our community are the direct result of unmet needs and a lack of acceptance of autism. Suicide should be seen as a response to a society that is not accepting of autistic persons at all. As autistic self-advocates we believe that autism is not a disorder that needs to be cured or should be stigmatized, but a lifelong neurological difference that is equally valid.

Our previous side events were concerned with moving from autism awareness to autism acceptance (2014), the worldwide pain and sorrow caused by medical experimentation on autistic children (2015), and the devaluing of autistic behaviours and the use of physical and mechanical restraint and seclusion in schools (2016). These themes echoed throughout 2017's presentations. All the experiences we previously laid out before the Committee contribute to a sense of doom and futility that causes depression and suicidal ideation in autistic individuals.

Even though the speakers last year hailed from western countries, autistic persons are one percent of the population in any given country, albeit many of us remain undiagnosed or misdiagnosed due to a shortage of medical professionals qualified to diagnose autism in less developed countries. Many of us are counted for in suicide statistics the world over, without our deaths ever being linked to autism or the societal attitudes and barriers we faced and weren't able to overcome. Ours is an often hidden disability, and our deaths are hidden also.

No other age group illustrates the pressures exercised on us to hide and pretend to be "normal" as much as that of older persons on the autism spectrum, who are nearly invisible. With Asperger syndrome in particular not being diagnosed before the mid-1990s, most autistic adults, who in their majority are not intellectually disabled, never received a diagnosis as a child. Many previously undiagnosed or misdiagnosed adults now finally get an autism diagnosis, often subsequent to a child or grandchild being diagnosed as being on the autism spectrum. Regardless, little attention is paid to autistic adults and even less to elderly autistic persons. When talking about autism, most people still only think of children.

In many countries, support and services for autistic persons end when they reach adulthood. Families are growing increasingly concerned about what will happen to their children and dependent autistic adults when they are not able to take care of them anymore. Autistic adults may age prematurely, and research found that on average we die decades earlier than non-autistic persons, whether from suicide, frequent co-morbid health conditions and a lack of access to autism-appropriate health care, filicide (by relatives) or homicide (by caregivers).

Our side event and thematic briefing therefore sought to address health risks, premature mortality, ageing, and the rights of older persons on the autism spectrum from the perspective of the CRPD. All the examples presented from any one country were equally applicable to all other countries, in their respective context. The geographic origins of our speakers were not meant as a show of disrespect for other cultures and socio-economic situations, but owed to the uneven distribution of awareness of and knowledge about autistic adults and ageing on the autism spectrum.

It may seem frivolous also to talk about premature mortality in the autistic population when viewed from the perspective of countries with a much lower life expectancy in general, for persons with or without disabilities alike, but ultimately the right to life guaranteed by the CRPD applies to all, in all contexts, and any circumstances unduly shortening the life of persons with disabilities anywhere equally demand our urgent attention.

Autism in adulthood and old age may be hidden in most parts of the world, and our deaths may only be counted in suicide statistics, but those children everywhere diagnosed as part of the so-called autism "epidemic" will soon grow up and grow old and join us in demanding autism acceptance and an end to stigma and prejudice against autistic people. Many of us will be consumed by the fight for equality and succumb to depression, but others will take our place and fight on. We may die as individuals, but the worldwide autistic community will only grow stronger with age.

(Speakers' presentations are available upon request.)

Updated WHO factsheet on autism by Erich Kofmel

In April 2017, the World Health Organization (WHO) updated its factsheet on autism spectrum disorders that is supposed to provide key facts, data, and information on epidemiology, assessment, and management, social and economic impacts, as well as other related resources. While speaking of the human rights of autistic persons, they continue to undermine our human rights by using stigmatizing language such as "disorder" and "burden" and recommending early intervention and behavioural treatment (i.e. normalization, Applied Behaviour Analysis/ABA). The parent skills training programme they mention repeatedly was developed in collaboration with controversial US charity Autism Speaks, but without any input from actually autistic people.

http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/autism-spectrum-disorders/en/

Autism in UN report on mental health by Erich Kofmel

The United Nations Special Rapporteur on the right to health dedicated his 2017 report to the UN Human Rights Council to mental health. It includes a number of explicit mentions of autism and autistic persons.

"4. [...] Some have cognitive, intellectual and psychosocial disabilities, or are persons with autism who, regardless of self-identification or diagnosis, face barriers in the exercise of their rights on the basis of a real or perceived impairment and are therefore disproportionately exposed to human rights violations in mental health settings. Many may have a diagnosis related to mental health or identify with the term, while others may choose to identify themselves in other ways, including as survivors. [...]

"8. For decades, mental health services have been governed by a reductionist biomedical paradigm that has contributed to the exclusion, neglect, coercion and abuse of people with intellectual, cognitive and psychosocial disabilities, persons with autism and those who deviate from prevailing cultural, social and political norms. Notably, the political abuse of psychiatry remains an issue of serious concern. While mental health services are starved of resources, any scaled-up investment must be shaped by the experiences of the past to ensure that history does not repeat itself. [...]

"55. Adequate mental health services must be made available. In many countries, the limited mental health and social care available is based on a narrow biomedical model and institutionalization. [...] Services must support the rights of people with intellectual, cognitive and psychosocial disabilities and with autism to live independently and be included in the community, rather than being segregated in inappropriate care facilities. [...]

"58. Mental health services [...] must be culturally appropriate and acceptable to persons with intellectual, cognitive or psychosocial disabilities and with autism, adolescents, women, older persons, indigenous persons, minorities, refugees and migrants, and lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex persons. Many within those populations are needlessly medicalized and suffer from coercive practices, based on inappropriate and harmful gender stereotypes. [...]

"62. In particular, children and adults with intellectual disabilities and with autism too often suffer from institutionalized approaches and excessively medicalized practices. Institutionalizing and medicating children with autism, based on their impairment, is unacceptable. Autism represents a critical challenge to modern systems of care and support, as medical attempts to 'cure' the condition have often turned out to be harmful, leading to further mental health deterioration of children and adults with the condition. Support for them should not only address their right to health, but their rights to education, employment and living in the community on an equal basis with others. [...]

"91. The Special Rapporteur calls for leadership to confront the global burden of obstacles and embed rights-based mental health innovation in public policy. That includes State champions in international policy efforts, the leadership of professional psychiatry in assessing constructively its approach to the necessity for change, managers of mental health services leading change by example and municipal officials championing grassroots innovation. These champions must work in partnership with their constituents, including persons with intellectual, cognitive and psychosocial disabilities and with autism."

Full text of the report in English:

https://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G17/076/04/PDF/G1707604.pdf?OpenElement

Also available in French, Spanish, Arabic, Russian, and Chinese:

http://ap.ohchr.org/documents/dpage_e.aspx?si=A/HRC/35/21

Unfortunately, in a number of other places where autism should have been mentioned explicitly, it isn't (most importantly, with regard to legislation depriving people of legal capacity). Still, we feel that the mentions of autism are informed by discussions and interactions Autistic Minority International has had with the Special Rapporteur, and autistic self-advocates and allies should be using this report in our ongoing advocacy with the UN and national, regional and local governments.

UN Special Procedures online portal by Erich Kofmel

In the future, if you wish to make written submissions to any of the so-called Special Procedures (Special Rapporteurs, Independent Experts, and Working Groups) of the United Nations Human Rights Council (i.e. Special Rapporteur on Persons with Disabilities, Special Rapporteur on Health, Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, etc.), with regard to the situation of autistic people in your country or other human rights violations, you can use this new online portal that provides detailed guidance on how the process works and what information you will need to submit:

https://spsubmission.ohchr.org/

Call: Study on right to health by Erich Kofmel

The United Nations Special Rapporteur on the rights of persons with disabilities, Catalina Devandas-Aguilar, is currently preparing a study on the right of persons with disabilities to the highest attainable standard of health.

The study will be presented at the October 2018 session of the UN General Assembly.

You can download the questionnaire in English, French, or Spanish from this website:

http://www.ohchr.org/EN/Issues/Disability/SRDisabilities/Pages/StandardOHealth.aspx

The Special Rapporteur welcomes inputs from, among others, "organizations of and for persons with disabilities, civil society, [...] scholars, research institutions [...], community movements, and private individuals".

Submissions in English, French, or Spanish should be sent in accessible format (Word) to:  sr.disability@ohchr.org

Concise responses are encouraged, inclusive of relevant attachments where available.

Deadline: 30 March 2018

You should indicate if you have any objections with regard to your reply being posted on the OHCHR website.

If you have any input toward a possible submission by Autistic Minority International, please send it as soon as possible to: e.kofmel@autisticminority.org

Autism and witchcraft by Erich Kofmel

The United Nations recently held its first expert workshop on witchcraft. In 2018, witchcraft is still a popular accusation levelled at people who "don't fit in", particularly in Africa and among African diaspora communities. Thought of as either witches or bewitched, many of these children and adults are more likely on the autistic spectrum.

http://www.afrik-news.com/article17924.html

https://www.youshareproject.com/absence-autism-africa/

https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2012/mar/01/accusations-witchcraft-pattern-child-abuse

WAAD 2018: Autistic women and girls by Erich Kofmel

The United Nations has announced the theme for this year's UN World Autism Awareness Day, 2 April 2018: "Empowering Women and Girls with Autism"

http://www.un.org/en/events/autismday/

They write: "In November 2017, the United Nations General Assembly adopted a resolution drawing attention to the particular challenges that women and girls with disabilities face in the context of the implementation of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD). The resolution expresses concern that women and girls with disabilities, are subject to multiple and intersecting forms of discrimination, which limit their enjoyment of all human rights and fundamental freedoms.

"The 2018 World Autism Awareness Day observance at United Nations Headquarters New York will focus on the importance of empowering women and girls with autism and involving them and their representative organizations in policy and decision making to address these challenges.

"Girls with disabilities are less likely to complete primary school and more likely to be marginalized or denied access to education. Women with disabilities have a lower rate of employment than men with disabilities and women without disabilities. Globally, women are more likely to experience physical, sexual, psychological and economic violence than men, and women and girls with disabilities experience gender-based violence at disproportionately higher rates and in unique forms owing to discrimination and stigma based on both gender and disability. As a result of inaccessibility and stereotyping, women and girls with disabilities are persistently confronted with barriers to sexual and reproductive health services and to information on comprehensive sex education, particularly women and girls with intellectual disabilities including autism.

"Through dynamic moderated discussions with experts and advocates, the observance will examine the particular challenges that women and girls with autism face in this context.

"Other key issues to be addressed include challenges and opportunities in fully exercising rights in matters relating to marriage, family and parenthood on an equal basis with others, as underscored in Article 23 of the CRPD and in the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) adopted by world leaders at the United Nations in 2015 (SDG 5.6)."

Events at UN Headquarters in New York will take place only on 5 April (2 April being Easter Monday). Disappointing that once more they chose as a theme something that fits into the larger UN agenda on people with disabilities, rather than something autism-specific. Let's hope autistic women who are invited to speak at the UN will point out areas in which they are affected more or differently than other girls and women with disabilities and/or people with disabilities in general, for example Applied Behaviour Analysis (ABA) "therapies" that condition autistic girls to become compliant and thus more prone to sexual abuse.

The programme hasn't been announced yet, but if you are planning to be in New York, you can already RSVP.

CONF: Participation in public affairs by Erich Kofmel

The Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) was mandated by the UN Human Rights Council to develop guidelines on the effective implementation of the right to participate in public affairs, including action-oriented ideas on how to make this right real for autistic persons and other persons with disabilities.

They will be holding an informal regional consultation for Western Europe, Eastern Europe, Central Asia, and Other States (normally meaning Israel, USA, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand) at UN headquarters (Palais des Nations) in Geneva, Switzerland, on 9-10 April 2018. It is open to all civil society representatives, but no funding is available.

Register here: https://reg.unog.ch/event/23498/

Deadline: 30 March 2018